Coffee Makes You Black

Located at 2803 N Teutonia Ave in Milwaukee, WI, Coffee Makes You Black is more than just a restaurant—it’s an experience. With a menu brimming with comforting, soul-satisfying dishes, this local gem has become a beloved destination for food lovers craving a fusion of classic Southern flavors and creative twists on traditional recipes. Whether you're a long-time local or a first-time visitor, Coffee Makes You Black invites you to explore its diverse and mouthwatering offerings that are sure to please every palate.

A Taste of Home: The Menu at Coffee Makes You Black

The menu at Coffee Makes You Black is a perfect blend of Southern comfort food and innovative, modern touches. From appetizers and sides to refreshing drinks, every dish is crafted with love and care to bring a unique and satisfying experience to your table.

Appetizers & Sides That Wow

Start your meal with some of Coffee Makes You Black's delectable appetizers and sides. The Hush Puppies are crispy on the outside, tender on the inside, and perfectly seasoned to make your taste buds dance. Paired with Okra or golden, crispy French Fries, these sides are the perfect way to kick off your meal.

If you're in the mood for something a little lighter, the Coleslaw provides a refreshing crunch, balancing out the richness of other dishes. For something a little more substantial, Chicken Strips (3 Pcs) W/Fries offer a crispy and flavorful option that satisfies both kids and adults alike.

Delicious Entrees for Every Craving

When it comes to the main course, Coffee Makes You Black offers something for everyone. Their Spaghetti is a classic, with a rich, savory sauce and perfectly cooked noodles that bring a comforting sense of home. For those seeking a heartier meal, the Extra Sunday Dinner Sides give you a chance to create your own perfect plate with generous servings of soul food staples.

But the real showstoppers are the Tenders, perfectly seasoned and fried to a crispy golden brown. Whether you’re enjoying them on their own or as part of a meal, these tenders will leave you craving more.

Flavorful Drinks to Complement Your Meal

No meal is complete without a refreshing drink, and Coffee Makes You Black doesn’t disappoint in this department either. The restaurant’s Flavor Tea is a crowd favorite, offering a unique twist on the classic iced tea with a variety of fruity and herbal infusions. And if you’re looking for something creamy to balance out the heat of your dish, don’t miss out on their Cream drinks, which are smooth, rich, and utterly satisfying.

Reviews

Amanda L.

The food is always on point. They recently started the r&b brunch and the dj was live. Even when the dj is not present the music is good-- like our kin is running the play list. Keeps the vibes right. The service is always kind. Just need more people to get plates out. I'll wait tho... the food &vibes are just that good. IMO

Karen P.

In between my work trip, we savored a delightful southern breakfast at a quaint spot in Milwaukee. Intrigued by its name, reminiscent of a book I read in college, "Coffee Will Make You Black," we found ourselves in a former bank building transformed into a light-filled space adorned with African art and tributes to black culture. It was heartening to support an upbeat, black-owned business in a community facing economic challenges, a testament to resilience amid adversity. The atmosphere was refreshingly unpretentious. We settled into our seats with ease, greeted by the promise of attentive service. Sipping on a refreshing peach lemonade, accompanied by soulful tunes, we momentarily escaped to the ambiance of a grandmother's backyard porch. The most memorable moment came unexpectedly when an elderly host approached our table, engaging us in conversation. With a simple inquiry into our full names and a handshake, he proceeded to surprise both of us with insightful descriptions of our personalities, aspirations, and preferences, akin to deciphering astrological traits. While initially skeptical, his accurate portrayal of my own traits left me questioning whether he possessed clairvoyant abilities. Ultimately, whether fueled by intuition or practiced skill, the encounter provided a welcome respite, allowing us to immerse ourselves in a moment of positive connection and intrigue while enjoying home fries, scrambled eggs, pancakes, catfish and my fav, shrimp and grits.

Gerald R.

Had a get together this afternoon at Coffee Makes You Back. It is at 2803 North Teutonia. About 80 to 100 members from assorted Lutheran Churches met for a story telling party. The restaurant served wonderful ground and brewed coffee. I am not a coffee drinker, but my wife, who is, thought it was great. Their menu for this event was mashed or fried potatoes, cole slaw and chicken wings. Normally, their menu would be more extensive, but this was done for the sale of simplicity for this meeting. The potatoes were tasty, all separate, not overdone and mushy. The cole slaw had a little zing to make it really good without being spicy. The chicken wings were fantastic. When cooking for a big crowd like this, it would be easy to go to extremes of just undercooked or burnt. These were done to perfection! They were crunchy, very juicy and extremely flavorful. You knew that the people in the kitchen had a game plan and followed it to the letter. I will be going back for more in the very near future. As I write, y taste buds are salivating. Servers were attentive and courteous without being in the way. The servers seemed happy to be there. It showed in everything they did. The building is not fancy. It used to be a bank. Everything was clean and neat. There were no last minute fixes that had to be done. All were prepared. Hours are limited, but those chicken wings will keep me coming back for more, very soon.

L L.

Nice spot to visit. Food was seasoned well. Would recommend eating here Good prices.

Marina G.

Loved stopping here on Friday morning. I ordered the chicken and waffles and it did not disappoint. At the table we also got shrimp and grits and fried okra and fried green tomatoes, and they were delicious. Prices are fair and coffee was good. The staff are very passionate about their business and their history. Will definitely be back and recommend to my friends and family.